Annie Park Targeted for Town Homes 07 Jun 12

$97,000 for 4 acres of under-utilized city green-space to build $3,000,000 worth of badly needed and affordable town-homes in one of the most under-developed neighborhoods in Thief River Falls and … and it is a land transaction that puts all 4 acres back on the tax rolls.

What could be wrong with this picture? Nothing – until you realize the land was originally donated to the city in good faith by a local educator who felt it would be a beautiful place for children to play.

Florentine Hance Kozojed, a former school teacher, donated Annie Street Park, just off South St. Paul – land that had been in her family for generations – to the city for one dollar in 1966. This week the Thief River Falls City Council passed a resolution of support that would allow developers to apply for tax credits and TIFF financing to purchase and develop Annie Street Park as River Pointe Town Homes, affordable multi-family rental housing.

Community Development Director, Micheal Moore, told the Council Tuesday the resolution was conditional, the matter has not yet had a hearing before the Planning Commission – the entire issue pushed by a June 12th deadline for Federal Funding. The resolution passing on a 4 to 2 vote with Aldermen Floyd Erickson and Ken Schmalz opposed.

Florence’s son, Tony Kozojed, told the Council Tuesday he has no trouble with the developer, the same company that built Roseau Court, a new town home complex in Roseau. But Kozojed says the city needs green space – to fly kites, play flag football, practice soccer and walk the dog. He says there is no park that offers those options with the same accessibility of Annie Park – and he said once the green space is gone – it is gone forever.

The $97,000 paid to the city for the site would go directly to the Thief River Falls Park Department; funding that could go a long way to create a lasting and better used tribute to Florence that would also enhance the current city park system.

  • Stat

    I would appreciate if someone could explain how and when this property would go on the Tax role when they are applying under TIF. There are many cities and states that are in dire financial positions because of such programs. The city of TRF has enough TIF zones that current residents and property owners are forced to support through higher property taxes while outside developers reap the benefits. Please contact your County Commisioners, School Board, Mayor and City Council and let them know you are not willing to bear the burdon.

  • Dratman

    sad we grew up there city for who bring back the rink

  • Whereisthepoole

    not a hockey town take all the out door rinks where it all starts

  • no pool no housing

    http://www.trfradio.com/2012/06/07/annie-park-targeted-for-town-homes/ This IS NOT a good move for the city. There are those of us that live right across from the park that are NOT happy about this at all. The neighborhood people were NOT EVEN notified that this was going to be happening. Our kids play in the park…. baseball, football, kite-flying, Easter egg hunts. Many of the neighborhood kids learn how to ride their bikes in that park. The reason it’s not much of a park anymore is because the city keeps taking everything away from the park and never improving anything…. a couple years ago they took the baseball back stop away…. the ice rink hasn’t been put in there for many years…. IF THE CITY KEEPS TAKING EVERYTHING AWAY FROM THE PARK HOW IS IT SUPPOSED TO BE A WIDELY UTILIZED PARK. For those of you out there that think it’s a good move for the city… Bet you’d feel a whole lot different if the park was in YOUR neighborhood. Most of the neighbors bought homes in this area because of the park being here…. AND just one more thing….. ANNIE STREET PARK WAS SOLD TO THE CITY YEARS AGO FOR $1.00 WITH THE SOLE INTENTION OF IT REMAINING A PARK!!!

  • kent

    $97,000 to her family tax free you used it all these year just because you failed to maintain it now you think she would want something different bunch of thief wow town name starts with that

  • Dave

    This is typical Thief River Falls BULLSHIT! I grew up playing hockey at the annie rink, riding mini-bikes and snowmobiles in field, flying kites etc. Just keep taking away every place for kids to do anything in this town and see how you continue to screw the future for kids in this town! And why do we need all these new houses and apartments in town if the population never gets larger???

  • Steak Sandwich

    “A lasting and better used tribute” is an invalid argument.
    If that were true then, logically, we should tear down the Ralph Engelstad Arena and put up townhouses instead.
    After all, there are already plenty of places to skate and play hockey in TRF.
    Yes it was a gift from the heart meant to help the city, but this way we can sell the land and no longer pay for maintenance.
    That leaves more money for youth hockey, and Ralph would’ve wanted it that way.
    Again, both arguments are invalid.

  • choomba

    Why not take out the crappy trailor park across the street and leave the park?

  • St Paul’er

    They used to have an Ice Rink here, they need to put that back up for “this side of town”
    and then put back up the back stop, maybe update the Swings/slides etc. we don’t not need anymore low income housing over there that “we” have to pay for.

  • Vchase

    Depends on who you are here in TRF. Different family with different name and the City would have left it green.

  • Concerned Citizen

    The city should not take away land donated with the understanding that it would remain a park and sell it for the purpose such as they are doing. This location would be a great location for the community swimming pool, which we have been donating money to for years. The city complains there is no location for this pool, but why not Annie park? Save Annie Park!

  • Concerned Citizen

    What about the “under-developed” park we know as Alan-A-Dale Park??? There’s more acreage there than there is at Annie Street Park. Or the Greenwood Trails Recreation Park…there’s almost 50 acres there.

  • keep the park

    No one in that neighborhood is ever notified about ANYTHING that’s going on. Not the underpass project, not this, not anything. We don’t get to find out about anything until it’s put in the news for everyone else to read. Pretty pathetic if you ask me. Maybe the city should consider giving the RESIDENTS of this town a chance to vote on some of these changes. It’s OUR town. Let US have a say in what goes on instead of just pushing us around to do whatever the city council, mayor, developers, etc. want to do. But then again, I suppose that would mean we had people in charge who actually CARED about the community & what our actual best interests are. I’ll say it again – LET THE RESIDENTS VOTE BEFORE YOU TAKE OUR PARK AWAY!!

  • Daglo2004

    First the land by the cemetery, then Southtown park, now Annie, what next. I doubt if it will be the park across from the Swenson house or the park at the end of Sherwood where the geese play. The city used to be proud of their green spaces. They used to require every development to have land set aside for a playground for children. Now I believe that the developer just gives them the price of one lot. No sweat if the developer has TIF money.

    When are the citizens of Thief River Falls going to stand up to the council or are they just tired of being treated like their opinion is not valued.

  • Dogchasedacat

    where is the petition?

  • Concerned Citizen
  • Why not?

    This is a classic argument of wants vs. needs, something Thief River Falls is notorious for. If all of you would take a quick glance at google maps on that side of town you can clearly see that there are plenty of areas for kids to play. Lions Park, Ole Englestad Park (East Side is what I always called it growing up), and many forget about all the green-space at Franklin Middle School (Tennis/Basketball courts, football fields, baseball diamonds, and skate park) which are accessible to anyone at anytime unless they are being used for school events (All are less than .5 miles away from Annie Park). I grew up in this area in the early 90′s and I always found annie park to be a bit obsolete. The ground is not even close to being level and the trailer park (just across Greenwood St.) always kind of gave me the creeps so the neighborhood kids and I stayed away for the most part. Don’t get me wrong, I’ve had my good times at Annie as it was the place where I learned how to play baseball. However if the land could be sacrificed to provide a little more affordable housing then I think that’s a pretty fair tradeoff. One person argued “Why do we need more housing if the population stays the same” and my question to you is how do we expect to add to our population if there is no place for newcomers to live? I understand that people who live across from the park won’t appreciate the added traffic from both the townhouses and the overpass but in all honesty thats because there is absolutely zero traffic going to the park right now (it’s going to be a big contrast). Thief River is a town that wants to grow but there are too many things holding it back like the sky high taxes caused by things like the Ralph Englestad Arena (Gasp!). That badboy still operates at a loss year after year and don’t even get me started on how awful it is to watch a graduation ceremony in there. I’m just saying we should look at this with some objectivity and realize it’s one of the smarter things our city council has approved in a while. Annie Park is particularly unused when compared to the other areas I mentioned and if this area could be sacrificed to house more taxpayers then I say why not?

  • Steak Sandwich

    If the city needs more housing there’s plenty of empty land surrounding the city to start a development (which the city has done in the past with SouthTown and Sherwood). As to the park being obsolete I disagree. It’s great now and could be even better with only a small investment. For me the biggest issue is trust. When the land was sold it was done with the understanding and condition that it be used as a park. If the city is going to re-neg on promises, it hurts future possible donations. It’s winning the battle and losing the war.

  • Hmm

    I thought there was property west of the end of 1st street that can be used for multi-family housing. Is there a problem with allowing a private group making something and increasing the tax base. The public should not be in the business of taking opportunity away from private enterprise.

  • Dogchasedacat

    Hello,
    Please to visit the following online campaign, by iPetitions: http://www.ipetitions.com/petition/save-our-green-space-in-thief-river-falls-annie/?utm_medium=email&utm_source=system&utm_campaign=Send%2Bto%2BFriend

    Message:
    password is greenspace to sign it

  • Dogchasedacat
  • Dodchasedacat
  • Dogchasedacat

    Shame on the city for selling a gift. You should be ashamed of yourself. Mrs Kozojed in good faith gave the land away so many in her neighborhood had a place to play or take a walk with a dog. Just because it may not used by every person in the community doesn’t make it less important. A gift is a gift. The Ralph was a gift, are you selling that next? Is Nordhagen trying to make himself look good on his resume for an upcoming Senate election by putting TRF in the red and adding housing for a local business to help lure them to move to TRF? We need some new blood to run for some city offices to help Floyd Erickson which seems to be the only level head in there. Jody is supposed to follow the city councils directives, not the other way around, but I am afraid the are marching to her drum. this must be stopped. Why do we have a planning commission?

  • HOCKEY MOM

    THE RALPH IS A GREAT PLACE FOR OUR KIDS TO PLAY HOCKEY, IT IS THE WAY IT IS RUN THAT IS THE PROBLEM. ROSEAU AND WAROAD LET KIDS HANG OUT , IT IS MORE A COMMUNITY CENTER. a KID CAN GO SKATE FREE ANY TIME OF THE DAY OR NIGHT, BUT IF KIDS HANG OUT AT THE RALPH, THEY ARE TREATED LIKE 2ND CLASS SOON OT BE CRIMINALS. JUST LIKE THE CITY GETS RID OF THE GREAT OLD LANDMARK, THE OLD ARENA.

  • Franky

    wow dogchasedacat, it was not sold.

  • Citizen56701

    I think the right thing for the city to do is let the Kozojed family buy back the land for a dollar. To me it sounds as though the city is done using the property for what it was kindly donated for… a park. That way the Kozojed family can keep it or sell it so they can make $97,000. Either that or the city should take the $97,000 and put it into a park and name it after the Kozojed family. And I’m not talking about putting it into some park “general fund”, but into actual playground equipment and such FOR THE KIDS like the Kozojed family intended it for. I know this would never happen though. All the city sees is $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$.

  • Shaugen

    If the city no longer wants the park, the first option should be to sell it back to the family for what they paid for it.

  • Shaugen

    The VOTE we need to make is to vote OUT all the council members and any other official that is voted in that is in favor of this happening. Write it on your wall at home so we do not forget about it when elects come.

  • Gtc

    This is so true. We need new younger city council members. Not old people in charge that try make a old folks retirement town. Drugs and booze is good for kids right trf!!!

  • Annie Neighbor

    I live by Annie Street Park and my family does use the park. We would use it more if it were kept up better by the city. The ground at the park is so uneven, you have to be careful if you are running that you don’t twist your ankle. I think part of the reason that the ground is uneven is from the city dumping snow there in the winter. When the back stop was there, my women’s softball team used the park for batting practice. If the backstop was still there, my kids would use that now. If they put an ice rink there in the winter again, we would use that also. I also think using part of Annie park for a city pool is a great idea. The city doesn’t think its a central enough location. Right now a lot of people drive to Red Lake Falls and Warren to go to their pools. That’s a lot further than driving across town. It might not be practical to put in newer play equipment in since Lion’s Park is so close, but its nice to have a big area there to play baseball, football, soccer, fly a kite, etc. You can’t do that at Lion’s park.

  • Anonymous

    I like the comment about the Ralph usage. I agree that it’s the “city baby” & nobody can touch it unless you have cash. I can’t hardly afford to skate with my family. Yes there are outdoor rinks, but why can’t we skate at the Ralph with better conditions for young ones? This great gift seems to be a burden & nothing but a feather in TRF’s cap, but if people outside this city only knew how much of a pain it is, they would laugh. I agree with all that’s been said about the park preservation. Not so much about the pool being there. It will be spray painted & destroyed in a week over there. Cruel or not, it’s reality.

  • RDtune

    I think we should ask the City Council if they are going to pay the developers who had to set aside property for a park, that they are now going to sell for building lots. The developer who started Southtown had to set aside an area for a park. Now the city is going to develop the park to sell for building lots.

    They are putting in water and sewer and surfacing the road. Guess what….they had a cave in because no one took a core sample or talked to people in the community who could have told them about the water table in Southtown.